Handover of rehab flats does not amount to completion of redevelopment projects: HC
MUMBAI, Nov. 17 -- The Bombay High Court has ruled that handing over rehabilitation flats to original residents does not amount to completion of a redevelopment project, making it clear that developers remain responsible for completing construction as per sanctioned plans and obtaining an occupation certificate (OC).
The court directed two developers involved in the redevelopment of a housing society in Kurla East to hand over all original project documents, allowing the society to appoint another builder or undertake self-redevelopment. The developers were also restrained from obstructing the society's decision.
The court noted that while seven of the nine floors planned for the redeveloped building had been constructed and the original occupants rehoused, the project remained incomplete. The developer had also sold nine of the 10 flats proposed on the yet-to-be-constructed eighth floor.
"Merely because the members were given possession of their rehabilitation flats, their right to have the building completed according to the sanctioned plans and to obtain occupation certificate does not come to an end," a single-judge bench of justice Amit Borkar observed in an order passed earlier this month.
The court directed the developers to hand over, within two weeks, the original development agreement dated December 13, 2007, the supplemental agreement dated May 5, 2012, the deed of assignment dated November 9, 2015, commencement certificates, approved plans and no-objection certificates obtained for the project.
The Nehru Nagar Amrapali Co-operative Housing Society (NNACHS) had approached the high court seeking the original documents relating to the redevelopment of building no. 133 at Nehru Nagar, Kurla East, which began 18 years ago. The society contended that it had terminated its agreement with developers Rebuild and Pearl Concept Habitat (PCH) LLP, and that they had no right to continue with the project. Under the original agreement, the developer was to redevelop the society's ground-plus-four-storey building, which housed 40 members. Each member was promised a carpet area of 323 sq ft, along with a niche and flower bed area.
While Rebuild constructed seven of the nine planned floors, Pearl Concept Habitat took over the project in 2015 after Rebuild ran into financial difficulties and could not complete the work. The court was also informed that the developers had accepted payments from new buyers for flats in the redeveloped building.
The society alleged that the developers had failed to obtain the necessary permissions for the upper floors and that the construction was of poor quality. The developers denied the allegations, maintaining that all 40 original members had been rehoused.
Justice Borkar observed that this was not a case where the developer had failed to undertake any construction. However, handing over possession of rehabilitation flats could not be treated as fulfilment of the entire redevelopment agreement.
The court clarified that the financial dispute between the society and the developer could be decided by an arbitration tribunal. However, it said the developer was also required to protect the interests of buyers....
To read the full article or to get the complete feed from this publication, please
Contact Us.