Despite Punjab's objection, all set for CJ's swearing-in today
Chandigarh, Sept. 7 -- The oath-taking ceremony of Punjab and Haryana high court chief justice-designate Ashwani Kumar Mishra will go ahead as scheduled at Punjab Lok Bhawan here at 9.30 am on Monday, despite the Punjab government's opposition to his appointment.
Punjab governor Gulab Chand Kataria will administer the oath of office.
Traditionally, the chief ministers of both Punjab and Haryana attend the oath-taking ceremony of the chief justice of the high court. However, in an unprecedented development, chief minister Bhagwant Mann is unlikely to attend Monday's ceremony. According to an official spokesman, Mann will leave for Delhi on Monday and is scheduled to meet jailed cabinet colleague Sanjeev Arora.
The development comes a day after the Punjab cabinet objected to Mishra's appointment as the full-time chief justice, demanding that the appointment and administration of oath be kept on hold until the state government's views are obtained and duly considered.
The state government has contended that the Union government notified the appointment without awaiting its views, in violation of the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) for appointment and transfer of chief justices and judges of high courts. The cabinet has also accused the Centre of bypassing Punjab's constitutional rights and termed the move part of a continued assault on the state's rights.
The Punjab and Haryana High Court Bar Association (PHHCBA), meanwhile, held an urgent meeting of its executive and condemned the Punjab government's stand.
The Bar body said the appointment of judges and chief justices of high courts was governed by the constitutional framework and the law declared by the Supreme Court concerning the judicial appointments process.
"Once the appointment has been made in accordance with the constitutional process, political disagreement cannot be permitted to undermine the authority, dignity or institutional independence of the judiciary," the body said in a statement.
The PHHCBA termed the Punjab cabinet's decision to hold a meeting on the issue a case of "executive overreach" and urged the government to preserve the sanctity of the high court and the dignity of the office of chief justice.
It said the Bar could not remain a "mute spectator" where actions or statements of the executive had the effect of "casting a political shadow over a constitutional process".
"The Bar will defend the rule of law, separation of powers and the independence, dignity and sanctity of the judiciary," it said.
The Bar Council of Punjab and Haryana (BCPH) has not officially reacted to the issue so far. Punjab advocate general MS Bedi is the chairman of the body. However, BCPH member Suvir Sidhu said judicial appointments, particularly to the office of chief justice of a high court, were governed by the constitutional scheme and could not be made subject to the approval or veto of an elected state government.
"Any attempt to condition the assumption of office of a chief justice upon executive consent is antithetical to the independence of the judiciary and the constitutional separation of powers. Punjab government must recall and withdraw its opposition," Sidhu said.
Senior Congress leader Sukhjinder Singh Randhawa condemned the AAP government's resolution opposing Mishra's appointment and questioned whether the Punjab government respected the independence of the judiciary.
Randhawa said the appointment of chief justices was governed by the constitutional process involving the Supreme Court Collegium and the Union government. While the Punjab government could express its views, he said, turning the appointment into a political confrontation was "deeply concerning".
"I strongly oppose any attempt to create the impression that the judiciary must first obtain the political approval of the ruling party," he said.
"Courts are not departments of the Punjab government. Judges are not political appointees. And judicial independence cannot be subject to the convenience of AAP," Randhawa said, urging the government to stop politicising the issue, respect the constitutional process and raise any objections through appropriate legal channels.
The Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) also criticised Mann for opposing Mishra's appointment as chief justice of the high court.
SAD vice-president Daljit Singh Cheema said anyattempt by the executive to question or influence judicial appointments undermined the independence of the judiciary and the constitutional separation of powers.
"The high court has delivered several strong judgments against the Punjab government, while matters concerning alleged corruption in the highest offices are reaching a crucial stage," Cheema said in a post on X, adding that creating a controversy around the judiciary at such a juncture raised serious questions about the government's intentions.
"The Shiromani Akali Dal has stood firmly for an independent judiciary and constitutional institutions. We will strongly oppose every attempt to weaken, intimidate or politically interfere with the judiciary," Cheema said....
To read the full article or to get the complete feed from this publication, please
Contact Us.