India, June 7 -- Historic property debates reveal enduring tensions between legacy and public purpose

The recent controversy surrounding notices issued to Delhi Gymkhana Club, frequented by some of the capital's most affluent and influential residents, has prompted several prominent voices to invoke the historical and heritage significance of the institution in its defence. Their arguments reminded me that, years ago, proposals had also surfaced to vacate Rashtrapati Bhavan itself. This may sound surprising, but the facts can be verified through official records. Importantly, the proposal did not emerge during Prime Minister Narendra Modi's tenure. Nor was it suggested by communist leaders or activist groups. Rather, it was proposed by n...