India, Nov. 17 -- Reuters reported on 13 November that the Central Pollution Control Board had instructed states in July to inspect recycling facilities, including 309 that handle electronic waste. The reporting described concerns about inflated claims and false paperwork. For electronics retailers, the immediate question is what evidence they can offer a customer who leaves an old handset or appliance at the counter.

A trade-in device can be suitable for resale or refurbishment. Other equipment needs to go to a recycler. Both routes can be legitimate, but a chain that records every item as a collection success and loses sight of it after pickup cannot tell where the device ended up. That uncertainty is particularly damaging when retailers...