WASHINGTON, Nov. 21 -- Mexican manufacturers seeking relief from US tariffs received another signal of progress from President Donald Trump on Friday, but not the terms needed to establish what an agreement would change. The central question remains which duties Washington would reduce, and when.

Trump said the United States was "getting close" to a trade deal with Mexico after meeting President Claudia Sheinbaum during his visit to Shenzhen, China. His assessment followed the Mexican leader's own description of advanced negotiations over vehicles, steel, aluminum and related products.

The two governments' accounts point toward a possible bilateral settlement, not a completed overhaul of North American trade. That distinction matters be...