New Delhi, Nov. 19 -- Uncollected garbage piles on streets are an inescapable sight in Indian cities, often cited as a menace that makes them unlivable. Such complaints about urban spaces broadly fall under the urban 'livability' discourse, which holds that civic issues in most Indian cities-massive garbage dumps, hazardous levels of air pollution, and long traffic hours-make it difficult for people to simply live in cities.

This is a reasonable complaint given the empirical realities of our urban spaces, but its framing hides more than it reveals about what is at stake in making our cities more livable.

A few weeks ago, writer Manu Joseph articulated, with good reason, a similar complaint about Indian cities. Referring to cities like B...