NEW DELHI, Nov. 16 -- The Supreme Court has expressed concern over the worsening pollution in the Yamuna despite substantial expenditure on cleaning the river and warned that states, Union Territories and districts could face penalties if water quality deteriorates along stretches under their jurisdiction.

A bench of Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan observed that the river's condition reflected widespread failures in civic administration across settlements along its banks. It pointed to 520 drains discharging wastewater into the Yamuna and questioned why successive cleaning initiatives had failed to deliver meaningful improvements.

The court directed the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) to monitor water quality at points where the Yamuna and major drains enter and leave each state, Union Territory and district. The monitoring mechanism is intended to identify where pollution levels increase and establish accountability for the deterioration.

The bench made it clear that authorities responsible for stretches where water quality worsens would be liable for penalties. It asked the CPCB to develop a formula for calculating environmental compensation, which governments could subsequently recover from polluters and negligent officials after conducting an inquiry.

The court also emphasised that preventing untreated sewage and industrial effluents from entering the river was essential to restoring its health. Merely constructing additional sewage treatment plants, it observed, would not resolve the problem unless pollution was stopped at its source.

The bench also highlighted serious inconsistencies in official records concerning encroachments along the Yamuna. It noted that the Yamuna Action Plan reported no encroachments on 35 water bodies and wetlands in Delhi's Zone 'O', while an annexure submitted by the Delhi government identified encroachments on all 35.

The court further observed that none of Delhi's 37 existing sewage treatment plants complied with every prescribed standard. It said the shortcomings demonstrated the need for stricter monitoring of treatment facilities rather than relying solely on additional infrastructure.

Invoking the principle of Common But Differentiated Responsibilities, the bench said states sharing the Yamuna must recognise the river as a single ecological system. Their responsibilities should reflect both their contribution to pollution and their capacity to address it.

The court directed all sewage treatment plants, common effluent treatment plants and government-commissioned biogas facilities to install tamper-proof smart energy meters within one month. These facilities must also provide live operational data and information on the quality of their discharge.

The CPCB was instructed to conduct surprise inspections every quarter to verify compliance. The court said environmental compensation could be imposed for each day of non-compliance, creating a financial deterrent against violations.

To strengthen enforcement, the bench directed central and state authorities to extend administrative, technical and logistical assistance to the pollution control board. It also ordered public and private operators of wastewater and effluent treatment infrastructure to provide unrestricted access to their premises, equipment and records for inspections.

The CPCB and its designated agencies, including technical institutions and accredited laboratories, must be allowed to undertake surprise sampling, examine monitoring equipment and conduct technical assessments without obstruction.

The court directed police commissioners, district magistrates and superintendents of police to provide assistance to inspection teams whenever requested by the CPCB.

It also ordered the chief secretaries of Yamuna basin states and Union Territories, along with secretaries of the concerned central ministries, to nominate senior nodal officers within two weeks. These officers must be of at least Special Secretary rank and will coordinate with the CPCB to ensure compliance with the court's directions.

The bench additionally stressed the importance of protecting Delhi's Zone 'O' as a green zone. It called for the removal of existing structures in accordance with the law, while ensuring rehabilitation for occupants legally entitled to it.

The directions form part of the Supreme Court's continuing proceedings concerning the remediation of polluted rivers, particularly the Yamuna.

The court's intervention places greater emphasis on measurable improvements in water quality, institutional accountability and enforcement against polluters, as authorities face renewed scrutiny over the effectiveness of river-cleaning programmes.

Published by HT Digital Content Services with permission from Millennium Post.