New Delhi, Nov. 16 -- When HCLTech's CEO and MD reportedly received a CTC of about Rs 175 crore in FY 2025-26, an increase of nearly 67 per cent over the previous year, it was not merely a boardroom footnote. It was a statement about what corporate India considers valuable and what it considers disposable.

The company's own disclosures reportedly place his pay at around 291.9 times the median remuneration of its global workforce. Meanwhile, median employee remuneration rose by only 5.4 per cent. The issue now is whether a compensation culture that can increase one executive's pay by nearly two-thirds in a single year, while entry-level and mid-level hiring remain constrained, is economically rational or socially defensible.

The Arithmetic of Excess

Twenty-five per cent of a Rs 175-crore CTC is roughly Rs 43.75 crore. If that amount were redirected towards new entry-level or junior-to-mid-level roles at an average annual CTC of Rs 6 lakh, it could fund approximately 729 jobs. At Rs 4 lakh per job, it could support nearly 1,100 positions. At Rs 8 lakh, it would still create more than 540 roles. India's labour market is vast: the Periodic Labour Force Survey puts the unemployment rate for persons aged 15 and above at 3.1 per cent under the usual status measure in 2025, while youth unemployment remained much higher, at 9.9 per cent. Urban unemployment was 6.7 per cent in October-December 2025, against 4.0 per cent in rural areas. No single company's pay bill can solve India's unemployment problem. Yet, multiplied across India's largest corporations, the sums become consequential at the national level. If 25 per cent of excessive top-level compensation were redirected towards hiring across the corporate sector, the outcome could be enormous.

A Distorted Pay Pyramid

India's corporate pay pyramid is too steep to be defended as meritocracy. HCLTech's CEO reportedly earned Rs 27.8 crore in FY23. In FY26, the figure reportedly reached about Rs 175 crore. This is not an isolated case. An analysis of India's IT sector found that the median annual pay of the CEOs of five major IT companies rose by about 160 per cent over five years to nearly Rs 84 crore in FY24, while the median fresher salary rose by only 11 per cent, to Rs 4 lakh. Another report noted CEO-to-fresher pay ratios of 1,702 at Wipro and 1,383 at Tech Mahindra. These figures reflect compensation committees benchmarking against global peers, stock-linked awards and a governance culture that treats executive scarcity as priceless while regarding labour as a cost to be minimised.

The International Labour Organisation has long warned that India's wage inequality remains high. The India Wage Report recorded a wage Gini coefficient of 0.49 and a D9/D1 wage ratio of 6.7, while 33 per cent of wage workers, or 62 million people, were paid below an indicative national minimum wage. Corporate CTCs at the top may be legally earned, but when coupled with precarious entry-level work, stagnant fresher salaries and high youth unemployment, they become a macroeconomic and moral problem.

The False Defence of Talent Market

Defenders of inflated executive pay argue that India must offer global remuneration to retain global talent. There is some truth to this argument when it comes to genuinely scarce skills, yet it is overused. A CEO's value cannot be assessed solely by revenue growth or share-price performance; it is also shaped by the brand, workforce, inherited client relationships, macroeconomic conditions, tax policy, currency movements and the labour of thousands of employees.

Moreover, if Indian companies can hire engineers, graduates and support staff at Indian salary levels, why must CEO compensation alone be benchmarked against Silicon Valley? The argument that India is a cost-competitive location for talent cannot apply only at the bottom of the pyramid. A company cannot simultaneously claim that Indian labour is inexpensive enough to justify global delivery models and that its chief executive must be paid as though he operates in the most expensive global labour market.

The governance issue is equally important. SEBI already requires listed companies to disclose the ratio of CEO remuneration to median employee remuneration, precisely because investors and the public need transparency in pay practices. Yet disclosure is not restraint. A company may disclose a pay ratio of 292 times and still face no meaningful consequences. Transparency without accountability becomes a ritual.

What Should Change

Populist wage caps that ignore business realities are not the answer. Instead, smarter, enforceable incentives are needed. First, listed companies should be required to publish not only CEO-to-median pay ratios but also CEO-to-fresher pay ratios, hiring numbers, attrition rates and the share of compensation spent on workforce development. Investors must be able to see whether a firm is building an organisation or merely enriching those at the top.

Second, stock exchanges and institutional investors should treat extreme pay ratios as a governance red flag. A CEO-to-median pay ratio in the hundreds may sometimes be tolerable, but a sudden 67 per cent jump in one year demands a detailed justification.

Third, tax policy should distinguish productive reinvestment from pure executive enrichment. Companies that demonstrably expand formal, long-term employment, especially for new workers, women rejoining the workforce and youth in Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities, should receive targeted incentives. Companies that accumulate gains at the top while suppressing entry-level hiring should not receive similar treatment.

Fourth, boards should link a meaningful portion of executive variable pay to employment quality: net new formal jobs, fresher hiring, training hours and reductions in contractualisation where it is used merely to avoid permanent employment obligations.

Finally, companies should adopt a shared prosperity clause in their compensation policies. If median employee pay rises by less than a defined threshold, any enhancement in top-executive variable pay above a specified limit must be deferred or redirected into an employee welfare and hiring fund. This would not prohibit high pay; it would make high pay conditional on broad-based value creation.

Jobs Are Not Charity

The strongest objection to this argument is that employment cannot be created through moral pressure alone. That is true, yet neither can it be created by treating executive compensation as sacrosanct. Companies hire when demand exists, margins permit and leadership chooses to invest in capacity. Compensation design influences all three.

Redirecting Rs 43.75 crore from one executive's CTC may not transform India. Yet it could pay for hundreds of salaries and career beginnings. Across corporations, a similar principle could transform a culture of extreme concentration into one of wider participation. The question before India's boards is not whether CEOs deserve rewards. It is whether a country with millions of young people seeking dignified work can afford compensation systems that reward a handful of individuals so disproportionately that the employment ladder is broken.

Viksit Bharat does not need less ambition. It needs a fairer definition of success, one measured not only by quarterly profits and a CEO's CTC but also by how many people corporations lift into productive, secure employment. Until that changes, the Rs 175-crore paycheque will remain legally permissible, yet hardly socially defensible.

Views expressed are personal. The writer is a Public Policy Expert, Registrar IIPA and Vice Chairman, PANIIT Alumni India

Published by HT Digital Content Services with permission from Millennium Post.