'Wrongful loss of liberty must be compensated'
New Delhi, Nov. 17 -- Every wrongful loss of liberty must be compensated adequately to give the victim a genuine opportunity to rebuild his life with dignity, the Supreme Court underlined on Monday, enhancing to Rs.30 lakh the compensation payable to a man who remained in jail for more than seven years even after being acquitted of murder.
Setting aside a Chhattisgarh high court order that had awarded him just Rs.2 lakh, a bench of justices Augustine George Masih and Sanjeev Sachdeva said compensation for wrongful incarceration cannot be reduced to symbolic or nominal monetary relief but must be substantial enough to help the victim regain financial independence, secure a sustainable livelihood, and overcome the material disadvantages caused by the unlawful deprivation of liberty.
"The object of compensation in cases of wrongful incarceration ought not to be confined to providing merely symbolic or nominal monetary relief; rather, it must serve as a meaningful remedial measure capable of assisting the victim in rebuilding his life and restoring, to the extent possible, the opportunities and independence of which he has been deprived," it noted.
The case concerned Devilal Gond, who was arrested in December 2012 in a murder case and sentenced to life imprisonment by a trial court in August 2013. The Chhattisgarh high court acquitted him on January 20, 2018, setting aside his conviction and sentence. However, the acquittal order was never acted upon by the prison authorities, and Gond continued to remain behind bars until May 19, 2025 -- a further seven years, three months and 29 days after his acquittal. The state government attributed the prolonged detention to a communication and coordination failure between the prison authorities and the concerned legal aid functionaries. The jail superintendent had written to the panel lawyer in April and June 2018 seeking the status of Gond's appeal, but the outcome of the proceedings did not reach the prison administration. The discrepancy was eventually detected during a records verification exercise in May 2025, following which a release warrant was issued.
Calling the episode a case of "complete remissness" and "institutional dysfunction", the Supreme Court said Gond had lost the prime years of his youth because of the authorities' apathy and failure to act with promptitude. He was around 28 when he was acquitted and 35 when he was finally released.
The bench noted that the prolonged incarceration deprived him not merely of his liberty but also caused physical and mental hardship, loss of family life and livelihood, and denied him opportunities for education, skill development and advancement in his earning capacity.
"No monetary award can fully compensate for the loss of liberty, time, and opportunities that can never be restored," said the court, adding that this could not become an excuse for denying a victim a practical, effective and proportionate remedy.
It underlined that enabling a wrongfully incarcerated person to regain self-sufficiency and rebuild his life was not an act of charity or benevolence by the state, but the bare minimum required to redress the injustice inflicted upon him.
The court directed Chhattisgarh to pay the enhanced compensation within four weeks. Of the Rs.30 lakh, Rs.5 lakh will be transferred to Gond's savings account, while the remaining Rs.25 lakh will be placed in an interest-bearing fixed deposit in his individual name. The monthly interest will be credited to his savings account. He will not be permitted to withdraw or prematurely encash the deposit, or take a loan against it, without the permission of the district legal services authority.
The judgment also flagged the absence of a legislative framework in India to compensate and rehabilitate people who suffer wrongful incarceration, observing that constitutional courts have granted such relief in individual cases, without making it readily accessible to everyone.
Referring to the earlier rulings, the bench said that constitutional courts can award monetary compensation under Articles 32 and 226 for established violations of fundamental rights. Such compensation is a public law remedy founded on the principle of strict liability, and the state cannot invoke sovereign immunity to escape responsibility for violations committed by its officials....
इस लेख के रीप्रिंट को खरीदने या इस प्रकाशन का पूरा फ़ीड प्राप्त करने के लिए, कृपया
हमे संपर्क करें.