No pension for staffers, says HC, 9 yrs after DD show shut
MUMBAI, Aug. 3 -- Nearly a decade after Balchitravani, the State Institute of Educational Technology (SIET) that once brought educational programmes to children across Maharashtra through Doordarshan, wound up, the Bombay High Court has closed the legal chapter for two of its former employees, ruling that they were not state government servants and therefore not entitled to pension benefits.
The ruling, delivered while dismissing petitions filed by Ravindra Bidkar and Ramdas Shendge, also revisited the journey of an institution that, long before the internet and search engines became household tools, served as an educational gateway for children, particularly in rural Maharashtra. Established in 1984 and formally shut down in 2017 after becoming financially unviable and technologically obsolete, Balchitravani was once known for research-based educational programming on Doordarshan.
Bidkar, formerly employed as a painter, and Shendge, who worked as a khalasi (general helper), had challenged an August 11, 2023 order of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal (MAT), which rejected their claim that they should be treated as state government employees entitled to pension.
In order to decide whether the petitioners were government servants, the high court traced the evolution of SIET from its inception to its eventual closure.
The central ministry of education and culture decided in 1982 to establish SIET to produce research-based educational audio-visual content for children to be telecast on Doordarshan. Following discussions between the Centre and the state government, SIET was established in 1984. Initially based in Worli, Mumbai, it shifted its headquarters to Pune in 1986.
Funded by the Centre for its first five years, SIET became an autonomous body in 1991 and was registered as a society the following year.
Through Balchitravani, children across Maharashtra watched programmes that simplified subjects such as history, science, the state's culture, flora and fauna, and the lives of eminent personalities. The programmes frequently featured children from schools across the state in skits and dance performances. The content enjoyed particular popularity in rural Maharashtra, where it became an important educational resource well before the digital era.
However, SIET's fortunes began to decline in 2003 after the Centre withdrew financial support and the state government expressed its inability to take over funding and finally came to an end through a government resolution dated May 31, 2017.
Following SIET's closure, former employees argued before the MAT that 120 posts had been created with the approval of the state government's finance department and carried pay scales identical to those of state government employees. This, they contended, made them "government servants for all practical purposes" and entitled them to pension benefits. After the tribunal rejected their plea in 2023, Bidkar and Shendge approached the high court.
The high court acknowledged the circumstances surrounding the closure of Balchitravani.
It observed that Balchitravani was shut down "due to technological advancements and availability of alternative platform, there was no longer any need for a separate state-level Educational Technology Institute (Balchitravani).
Justices Suman Shyam and Shyam Chandak, in their recent order, held that persons who were never appointed to a civil post under the state government could not claim the status of "government servant".
The court also noted that since the petitioners had not retired from service upon attaining the age of superannuation, they did not satisfy the eligibility requirements under the pension rules. Consequently, the high court dismissed their petitions....
इस लेख के रीप्रिंट को खरीदने या इस प्रकाशन का पूरा फ़ीड प्राप्त करने के लिए, कृपया
हमे संपर्क करें.