New Delhi, Nov. 16 -- Despite US Secretary of State Marco Rubio's recent visit to India, tensions remain high between Washington and New Delhi. While the US midterm elections have boosted the opposition Democrats, the executive branch retains the leading role in American foreign policy. To discuss the state of the relationship and how bilateral security cooperation relates to India's military modernisation, veteran international relations scholars Sameer Lalwani and Anit Mukherjee joined a recent episode of "Grand Tamasha", a weekly podcast on Indian politics and policy coproduced by HT and the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Lalwani is a senior fellow in the South Asia Program at the Carnegie Endowment in Washington, DC and previously worked at the United States Institute of Peace and the Henry L. Stimson Center. His work explores military technology competition, deterrence dynamics, alliance politics, and Indo-Pacific security. Mukherjee became director of Carnegie India in New Delhi on 1 July. He previously taught at King's College London and the Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore. The two spoke with host Milan Vaishnav about US-India relations, India's defence and military reforms, and what Washington and New Delhi misunderstand about one another. Lalwani struck an optimistic note on the state of bilateral relations. "The trade numbers are up, the exercise numbers are up, private sector transactions and collaborations and investments are all going up. I think that speaks to two open societies and capitalist markets that work well together and see eye-to-eye on the balance of power in the Indo-Pacific," said Lalwani. He also pointed to Rubio's visit, his second to India in five months. Lalwani added that the US, even under Trump 2.0, recognises that "it needs to have a vibrant and powerful relationship with India to achieve its long-term strategic aims in the Indo-Pacific. That, to me, is the strongest evidence for the durability of the relationship." Mukherjee agreed that "the relationship is better than it looks," but offered a more sobering assessment, arguing that "the US-India relationship is in the worst position it's been in the past 20 years." He said that American actions on trade, tariffs, immigration, and Pakistan have allowed "a constituency in India that was already sceptical of America to say, 'See, we told you so; you cannot trust them.' "While India's strategic community still sees a logic to closer ties, recent events have created 'significant headwinds.'" Mukherjee nevertheless dismissed fears of a US-China rapprochement as overblown. "They might come together tactically on certain issues for a brief period, but I think we all know that they are locked into this geopolitical competition that exists across different sectors and in different theaters," he said. "I don't think India is that concerned about US and China coming together. I think India is more concerned about what increasing Chinese assertiveness means for itself, not just along the borders, but also in terms of its own trade engagement with China." Lalwani challenged those in Washington who "make the argument that India.will remain non-aligned and we should not make the effort to change the nature of India's foreign policy." He argued that formal mutual defence treaties may no longer inspire the same confidence-or provide the same deterrent effect-as they once did. This uncertainty, he suggested, creates room for new forms of security cooperation. "I think this is an opportunity for creativity in the space without a formal alliance, where a flexible one with creative language to describe it can take root," he said....