Censure can't by itself disqualify govt staffer from promotion: HC
JODHPUR, Nov. 20 -- The Rajasthan high court has held that government employees cannot be automatically denied consideration for promotion merely because they have been awarded minor penalties such as censure, ruling that executive circulars cannot impose a disqualification not provided under statutory service rules.
The court also clarified that while disciplinary penalties may be considered by a Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) while assessing an employee's suitability, they can't be used to bar employee from being considered for promotion altogether.
A bench comprising chief justice Sanjay K Agrawal, justices Sameer Jain and Pramil Kumar Mathur delivered the verdict on Wednesday while answering two questions referred to it by a division bench in a case involving the State and Ajay Kant Ratudi (Sharma), a police officer.
The reference arose after Ratudi, who was appointed as a sub-inspector in 1996 and promoted to inspector in 2013, was awarded three penalties of censure in 2017, 2019 and 2021. He challenged the penalties and subsequently sought consideration for promotion to the Rajasthan Police Service (Junior Scale) despite the disciplinary actions.
The State had issued circulars prescribing a seven-year period during which penalties could affect promotion prospects. The full bench examined whether these instructions could prevent an employee from being considered for promotion when the statutory service rules did not prescribe such a disqualification.
The bench observed, "What the Rules forbid directly cannot be achieved indirectly by an executive instruction," holding that administrative circulars could not introduce restrictions inconsistent with statutory rules.
It further clarified that DPC retains the authority to assess an employee's service record, including disciplinary penalties, while determining suitability. "The mere existence of minor penalty(s) within seven years doesn't by itself create an automatic bar to consideration or an automatic finding of unsuitability," the bench held. It said a penalty could be considered as part of an employee's overall record....
To read the full article or to get the complete feed from this publication, please
Contact Us.