India, Nov. 22 -- Not too long ago, there was a spate of two- or three-day Test finishes where the blame was immediately passed on to the pitch, followed by the usual ICC reviews and the consequent poor rating or a demerit point. That thought probably won't cross the mind in the aftermath of the Basin Reserve Test. Yet there is something deeply incongruous about celebrating a massive total as an unqualified triumph.

To accumulate 720-the highest total in a Test innings in New Zealand-is a remarkable achievement. There is no doubt that KL Rahul's patience, Rishabh Pant's audacity, Shubman Gill's authority and the contributions of Yashasvi Jaiswal, Devdutt Padikkal and Dhruv Jurel were all worthy of the occasion. But it isn't necessarily a...