India, Sept. 26 -- The woman involved in an extramarital relationship with Caleb Flynn visited the parents of his deceased wife Ashley Flynn the morning following Ashley's death-while simultaneously harboring doubts regarding the circumstances, according to her testimony.

Alleigha Botner, 24, who maintained a romantic involvement with Caleb spanning nearly two years, provided testimony this week as he faces trial for Ashley's murder at their residence in Tipp City, Ohio, on February 16.

Caleb maintains that an unknown assailant entered the home and killed Ashley. Both Caleb and Botner served as worship leaders at the Christian Life Center, where Ashley's parents had maintained membership for many years, as confirmed by the church's past...