India, April 11 -- There's a certain expectation that follows creators who strike gold early. After the global success of Schitt's Creek, Dan Levy returns with Big Mistakes, a chaotic crime-comedy co-created with Rachel Sennott. Positioned as a star-driven follow-up in the streaming era, the show attempts to blend dysfunctional family comedy with a spiralling crime plot-but rarely finds the balance it's chasing.

Set in suburban New Jersey, the series follows Nicky, a tightly wound pastor hiding a relationship that could upend both his personal and professional life. He's pulled back into family chaos when his domineering mother Linda-midway through a mayoral campaign-insists he and his sister Morgan procure a meaningful gift for their ai...