Nepal, Nov. 16 -- On 7 February 2022, a 12th-century Uma-Maheshvara stele was reinstalled at Tangal Hiti, a stone water spout in Patan. It was stolen from there in the 1980s. The New York-based Metropolitan Museum of Art had received it as a donation in 1983 and returned it to Nepal in 2018. It took almost four years to reinstall it in Patan. Its eventual return to the shrine is a model for what restitution should mean.

It is rarely what happens. Of the artefacts returned from the United States in recent years, one is back in its shrine and two remain in museum galleries, while another sits in the British Museum without so much as a verified reply. The object has to return to the community that worshipped it every morning.

Hindus worshi...