India, Nov. 22 -- What hangs in the balance, for India and for every open society, is not whether any actor can shout louder; it is whether the quieter version works.

In Thomas Hardy's "In a Whispering Gallery", a whisper takes on the quality of a spirit's voice, near and unseen, and the listener cannot tell whether anyone stands at the other end.

A 399-page archive that Vanderbilt University's Institute of National Security published last September describes a system built to produce a similar effect, and contains a list Delhi should read closely. A Beijing data company's own materials list where it says its flagship product has been deployed: the Hong Kong and Macao Affairs Office, the Ministry of State Security and the Joint Staff In...