India, Nov. 18 -- Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal on Tuesday said the judiciary has protected press freedom in principle but not always in practice, arguing that courts have often intervened only after legal proceedings were initiated and applied safeguards inconsistently.

Delivering the Press Club of India's annual Foundation Day lecture on "Has the judiciary protected press freedom in the world's largest democracy?", Sibal said the question was whether the principle still held "when the journalist is detained for reporting, when the source is deterred by the threat of disclosure, and when the process of law becomes the punishment".

"The Constitution has already answered the question. The practice has not. That is the gap we must examine to...