
NEW DELHI, Nov. 19 -- The Supreme Court has clarified that its earlier directions to remove unauthorised encroachments along national highways cannot be used to demolish disputed structures without following due process of law, stressing that authorities must first establish whether the properties in question constitute illegal encroachments.
A bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh, in an order passed on Wednesday, November 18, granted affected property owners permission to approach the jurisdictional High Courts and directed that no coercive action be taken against the disputed structures until their cases are decided.
The clarification came on applications filed by property owners challenging demolition proceedings initiated by the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) and other authorities over alleged encroachments within the Right of Way (ROW) of national highways.
The proceedings arose from the Supreme Court's suo motu examination of road safety and highway encroachments following accidents in Rajasthan's Phalodi and other locations.
On April 13, 2026, the apex court had directed authorities to identify and remove unauthorised encroachments along national highways. However, the bench clarified that those directions did not determine whether any particular structure was an encroachment.
The court observed that a general direction to remove encroachments could not be treated as a final determination of the legal status of individual properties.
It emphasised that authorities could not rely on the earlier order to bypass statutory safeguards or exercise powers beyond those provided under the law.
The bench referred to Section 26 of the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002, which prescribes the procedure for removing unauthorised occupation of highway land.
The provision ordinarily requires authorities to issue a notice and provide affected persons an opportunity to submit their objections before taking action.
The court reiterated that compliance with statutory procedures was essential to uphold the principles of natural justice, citing its earlier judgment in *Gyan Prakash v. Union of India*.
It held that the April directions could not independently justify dispensing with the requirements of the statute.
The applicants had raised disputes concerning ownership of land, demarcation of highway boundaries, the extent of the Right of Way and whether their properties had been legally acquired or compensation paid.
The bench observed that resolving such disputes could require examination of revenue records, land acquisition proceedings, survey reports and other relevant documents.
It clarified that merely claiming ownership or lawful occupation would not automatically prevent authorities from removing an illegal encroachment. However, an assertion by highway authorities that a structure fell within the Right of Way could not substitute for a lawful determination when that claim was disputed.
The court said competing claims must be examined under the applicable statutory framework, with affected persons receiving the opportunity for a hearing and adjudication required by law.
The bench accordingly directed the applicants to approach their respective High Courts for adjudication of their grievances concerning proposed demolition or removal of structures.
Those who had already initiated proceedings before the High Courts were permitted to pursue their cases.
The Supreme Court directed that existing interim protection granted to the applicants would continue until the High Courts disposed of the proceedings.
In cases where no interim protection had previously been granted, the court restrained NHAI and other authorities from demolishing or removing the disputed structures or taking other coercive action pursuant to the challenged notices until the High Courts decided the matters.
The High Courts were requested to examine the disputes expeditiously and in accordance with law.
The bench made it clear that it had not expressed any opinion on the merits of the property owners' claims or the correctness of the action initiated by NHAI and other authorities.
These questions would remain open for independent examination by the jurisdictional High Courts.
The court also clarified that the protection would apply only to the structures involved in the applications and would not confer any additional legal rights upon the applicants.
It said the interim relief could not be used to justify fresh construction or further encroachments along national highways.
Importantly, the Supreme Court maintained that its April 13 directions for removing unauthorised encroachments would continue to operate in their entirety, subject to compliance with applicable laws.
The clarification seeks to ensure that highway safety measures are implemented without denying affected property owners the legal remedies and procedural protections available to them.
Published by HT Digital Content Services with permission from Millennium Post.