New Delhi, Nov. 17 -- India's expanding network of national highways is often celebrated as evidence of economic ambition and infrastructural progress. Yet, beneath the impressive statistics of road construction lies an uncomfortable contradiction: roads built for high-speed mobility remain dangerously vulnerable to stray cattle wandering into traffic. The Supreme Court's latest intervention, asking the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) to consider establishing animal shelters near toll plazas, exposes a longstanding failure of governance. When motorists are expected to navigate expressways at considerable speeds while anticipating the sudden appearance of animals, the problem is no longer merely one of road management. It becomes a question of public safety, institutional accountability and the value placed on human life.

The NHAI's objections deserve examination, but they cannot become an excuse for administrative paralysis. Appearing before the Supreme Court, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta argued that the authority lacked statutory powers to acquire land for cattle shelters and that implementing the court's directions could cost more than Rs 5,000 crore. These concerns are not entirely without merit. Highway construction and animal welfare fall under different administrative jurisdictions, and compelling a road-building agency to operate shelters across the country could create operational complications. Nevertheless, the distinction between statutory responsibility and public obligation cannot be stretched indefinitely. An institution entrusted with maintaining national highways cannot reasonably distance itself from a recurring hazard that directly threatens their safe use. The court's suggestion that the NHAI contribute financially towards shelters offers a possible middle ground, provided the arrangement rests on a clear legal framework and enforceable responsibilities.

The deeper problem lies in India's fragmented approach to stray animal management. Municipal bodies, panchayats, state governments, animal husbandry departments and highway authorities operate within overlapping spheres of responsibility, frequently leaving dangerous gaps in implementation. Cattle abandoned after becoming economically unproductive often find their way onto roads, where inadequate fencing, poor monitoring and ineffective removal mechanisms turn them into hazards. The consequences extend beyond motorists. Animals themselves suffer injuries and death in collisions, while emergency responders confront preventable tragedies. Treating the problem exclusively through the construction of gaushalas would therefore be insufficient. India needs coordinated systems for identifying vulnerable highway stretches, promptly removing animals, providing humane shelter and ensuring that abandonment does not remain an unchecked practice.

There is also a fundamental question of accountability. Highway users pay tolls with the legitimate expectation that the infrastructure will meet reasonable standards of safety. A road cannot be considered adequately maintained merely because its surface is smooth and its lanes are properly marked. Safety must encompass everything that makes travel predictable, including protection against animal incursions. Dedicated response teams, functional fencing at vulnerable locations, reliable reporting mechanisms and coordination with local administrations should become measurable elements of highway management. Financial constraints may determine how these measures are implemented, but they cannot justify their indefinite postponement.

The Supreme Court's intervention should ultimately encourage institutional reform rather than another prolonged dispute over jurisdiction. The responsibility for preventing highway deaths must be shared without becoming so dispersed that nobody can be held answerable. Clear funding arrangements, defined operational duties and independent monitoring would provide a more durable solution than isolated directions. India cannot claim to possess world-class highways while accepting preventable deaths as an unavoidable consequence of travelling on them. Infrastructure becomes meaningful not when it merely connects destinations, but when it ensures that people can reach them alive.

Published by HT Digital Content Services with permission from Millennium Post.