'Being a bright child no grounds to quash FIR on Op Sindoor'
MUMBAI, Sept. 20 -- The Bombay High Court on Friday refused to quash a First Information Report against a 19-year-old engineering student who was arrested in May 2025 for re-posting controversial posts on social media allegedly in support of Pakistan during India's 'Operation Sindoor' that began on May 7, when Indian armed forces bombed nine terror camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir.
Remarking that it is a serious matter, a division bench of chief justice Shree Chandrashekhar and justice Gautam Ankhad told the petitioner's counsel that the court can grant her bail but not quash the FIR on the ground that she has tendered an apology or is a bright student. "This is a very serious thing. That's fine, you are a bright child, but that cannot be a ground to quash the FIR," the court said.
The student had approached the Bombay High Court after she was arrested on May 9. Seeking to quash the FIR against her, she said she was rusticated from her college post the event and was later remanded in judicial custody. During the hearing on Friday, her counsel submitted that the intention behind the post was not to hurt any sentiments.
"She is a student and had merely re-shared a post on social media. When her friends told her that the post was inappropriate, she immediately deleted it. The person who originally created the post has not been booked, but only she has been proceeded against for having shared it," he said.
However, the court remained unconvinced and said that a bail can be considered in view of her status as a young student, but the FIR will not be quashed. "Being a bright student is not a sufficient reason to quash the FIR. It is irrelevant that the post was later deleted. In fact, deletion may aggravate the incident," said the court.
According to the student's petition, she had re-posted a post from a user named 'Reformistan'. It read: "Without a single shred of evidence for Pak's involvement at Pahalgam, the fascist Indian regime has just initiated war between 2 nuclear states by bombing 3 major civilian areas in Pakistan. This Hindutva-terrorism is right out of the Israeli playbook... May sense, justice, and humanity prevail."
The petition states that she had to face public humiliation, and casteist abuse both within and outside the college campus. "Although she deleted the post following the controversy, she was rusticated from the college, which claimed she had anti-national sentiments and posed a risk to the campus community and society," it added. The student's counsel submitted before the court that the college's action appeared to have been influenced by prevailing political and public sentiments rather than any objective assessment of facts or adherence to due process.
The bench directed the additional public prosecutor Mankunwar Deshmukh to submit the case diary in a sealed cover before the court. The matter was posted for final hearing in two weeks....
To read the full article or to get the complete feed from this publication, please
Contact Us.